Is "Tall T" For Terror, Tall, or a Tall Or Terrible Ranch?
Greenbriar's Tall T Way Of Life Enhanced by HD
T Is For Terror? Now I Am Confused. |
Willard Mims (John Hubbard) Is Yellow, Selfish, and No Good, But He Does Save Lives |
Richard Boone Explains To Randy That a Western Is Only As Good As Its Principal Heavy |
3 Comments:
Dick Dinman remembers a 1957 encounter with "The Tall T" at Jones Beach, with "Loving You" for a warm-up! ---
Hey John, I have vivid memories of the first time I saw THE TALL T which is one of my five or six all-time favorite westerns. It was summer and my mother and I took the train to Jones Beach which then necessitated a transfer to the bus that would take us directly to the beach. The bus terminal was across the street from a neighborhood Loew's theater which was playing the Presley film LOVING YOU which interested me not a whit but I happened to notice that the barely visible on the marquee second feature was THE TALL T and since I made it a point never to miss a Scott film (easy to do in N.Y.) I convinced my mother to drop me off at the theater while she continued on to the beach. I remember grudgingly tolerating the last half of LOVING YOU (and being aghast at how much Lizabeth Scott had aged) but after ten minutes of THE TALL T I knew even then that this was a very special film and it remains to this day , along with RIDE THE HIGH COUNTRY, one of my two favorite late career Scott films. I consider it a masterpiece from first frame to last. Cheers, Dick Dinman
I agree with you about Burt Kennedy. When I saw Scott-Boettichers like Decision at Sundown that he didn't script, the films were a disappointment.
However, I'm also disappointed by the westerns I've seen that Kennedy directed. They also don't live up to his work with Boetticher.
Boetticher and Kennedy were good, but they were much better together.
I'm putting my vote in for Boetticher-Kennedy being better than Kennedy alone, but Boetticher alone has some very fine films (notably The Bullfighter and the Lady and The Killer is Loose) without Kennedy (or Scott). The fairest thing to say is that when you had a dry, spare, tough script from Kennedy, Boetticher had just the virtues of rendering it in a dry, spare, tough fashion that didn't screw it up and achieved its full cinematic potential.
The other figure here is Harry Joe Brown, who produced most of the Boetticher-Scott westerns. He too, at minimum, knew how not to screw these up, and probably played a major role-- as did Scott-- in encouraging Kennedy to write without concern for conventional commercial sentiment. (Cinesation just played a silent Ken Maynard that Brown directed, and even in 1930 it's got a tough, no-BS tone that Scott et al, wouldn't have disapproved of in the least.)
So I don't think anyone is the auteur of the Scott-Boetticher films-- I think they had a team in rare sympathy at work on them.
Post a Comment
<< Home