Lorre + Literary + Sternberg
Crime and Punishment (1935) Comes To The Talking Screen
Peter Lorre is so twitchy after committing murder as to alert a dumbest observer of his guilt, but fun's in seeing him march the course toward owning up. How much of this is Dostoevsky? I've not cracked a binding on any Russian novel, let alone impenetrable Fyodor (yes, that's his first name ... did you know? ... I didn't). Direction is Von Sternberg, each shot B/W painterly, and reason to watch even when Lorre outstays patience. I like this actor, perhaps best at lower dosage. He's teamed with Edward Arnold in a way that anticipates later pairings with Sydney Greenstreet at Warner Bros. Did writers there consult Crime and Punishment for ideas?
A C&P Still Taken by von Sternberg |
6 Comments:
I liked this movie a lot, and although Edward Arnold did a good job, his American accent and demeanor kind of threw me for a while.
Arnold and Lorre signed for The She Creature '56. When Arnold died, Lorre presumably ran for the exit. He never did cross paths with AIP til the later color Cormans.
The sly investigation technique of Edward Arnold's detective in the film reminded me somewhat of Peter Falk's "Columbo."
Not a coincidence --- Lt. Columbo was deliberately patterned after the detective in CRIME AND PUNISHMENT.
This version of CRIME AND PUNISHMENT works the exterior of the novel well enough, but misses the "guts" of it.
It's been a long time since I've read it, but it's my recollection that von Sternberg had little good to say about CRIME AND PUNISHMENT in his autobiography. After Paramount, a stint at Columbia must have seemed demeaning to him.
Lorre reprised this role on radio in 1947, on a summer series he starred in titled MYSTERY IN THE AIR, the scripts for which all seemed designed to build to a scene where he could pull out all the stops -- most of them, anyway -- with his over-the-top theatrics. That may have been a bit much to take on a weekly basis. But, as one reviewer of the series noted, you don't hire Peter Lorre and then expect him to play the part as if he was Herbert Marshall.
Terry and Denis Sanders, fresh off their acclaim with their student film "A Time Out of War," had their go at Dostoyevsky in "Crime and Punishment, USA," starring the young George Hamilton.
Post a Comment
<< Home