Watch List for 7/7/2025
Watched: Looking for Mr. Goodbar, A Hatful of Rain, The Drum, and Five Fingers
LOOKING FOR MR. GOODBAR (1977) --- There should have been a Purple Heart awarded to Diane Keaton for toplining this massively unpleasant film. Having skipped Mr. Goodbar in 1977 (was never particularly fond of the candy either), how could I know it would disappear due to lapsed music rights, other underlies that keep so many features out of current circulation. OK to broadcast if anyone cares (like recent TCM), physical media but lately had, Looking for Mr. Goodbar till then a London After Midnight of downer 70’s output. I took TCM’s dip, won’t call it a bad picture, too well written/directed (Richard Brooks) for that, but holy cat, was the disco decade really so ugly as this? Current Code edicts would never let it be remade today, and at over two hours, Goodbar is ultimate instance of see once being sure enough. Still there is Ms. Keaton, who having heroically done this, eventually settled into old folk rom/coms and lately an elderly cheerleader movie where she, Pam Grier, and others revived spirit of Pom Poms (another candy reference). I met her at a Manhattan paper show back when they had paper shows in Manhattan (what happened to them? I miss Manhattan paper shows). She was searching 8X10 still stacks, having just released a book of cheesy 50’s publicity photos which I complemented, the right move for she liked hearing that as opposed to talk of movies (and more specifically Mr. Goodbar?). What she goes through in Mr. Goodbar is horrific, actor abuse I’d call it. The ending is like Blood Feast with strobe lights. Club scenes make Saturday Night Fever look like The Love Bug (speaking of other then-hits). That’s where now reclaimed music is heard, it what kept Mr. Goodbar locked up from what I hear. Men that Keaton meets and picks up are dreadful creeps, all capable it seems, of killing, and once again, I’m reminded that NYC is a fair place to stay away from. Goodbar goes Taxi Driver route, speaking of another to latterly shun, by me anyhow. Lure of Goodbar and likes is how intelligently designed they are, but so are crocodiles and cobras. Can PTSD come of exposure to certain films, or again am I too sensitive? Can’t say they bore, but tender sensibilities beware. Kudos to TCM for booking it, network’s value measured for odd outside pictures they bring from hibernation, no better instance than Looking for Mr. Goodbar.
A HATFUL OF RAIN (1957) --- Another rarity via TCM, here is hatful of then-live TV sensibilities poured over Cinemascope width that director Fred Zinneman disdained for this occasion, but Fox chief Buddy Adler said use it, so Zinneman dutifully did. He tells the story in his book, said Hatful got anything but that in revenues (“nobody saw it” FZ recalled). Fact is it lost lots, $1.8 for negative cost, $1.2 in domestic rentals, $917K foreign, eventual loss of $957K. None of networks cared, so off to syndication where I watched at age fourteen as entre to “grown-up” fare after years of late show monsters only. Don Murray as a dope addict seemed incongruous, still sort of does. At the time of seeing him in this, there was Liberty exposure to Murray as a Roman general in Hammer’s The Viking Queen. Don, we hardly knew ye. Substance addiction gets harsh Hatful revue, no quarter for Murray’s character being that way via torture by Reds while serving in Korea. A Hatful of Rain was based on a Broadway play, Anthony Franciosa ported over from that. We’ve seen Tony overplay, but when to such extreme as here? Makes him in The Long Hot Summer look lowkey. I kept wondering why these folk didn’t seek help from veteran’s services. Was such option not so readily available at 1956 time of Hatful shoot? Addiction was a stigma, period and exclamation. Once tagged as a doper, you were done. Much of A Hatful of Rain was shot on New York streets, and at night. You never saw Gotham so arresting, or spooky. What a shame this stayed off TV so long in scope, let alone HD. Again, TCM to the rescue. Hatful as kitchen sink hell evokes souped-up Playhouse 90’s, and didn’t 50’s viewers get enough of those from TV? Granted the drug theme could not have been hammered so hard on home screens. Thankful for opportunity to watch, and maybe I will again, but not for a while … a long while.
THE DRUM (1938) --- Could be it was thought in the thirties that if a film must be British, let it at least have plenty of riding and shooting to lessen tedium otherwise. Alexander Korda saw merit to that and so served action he could sell worldwide, The Drum a first too for Technicolor with which Korda further enhanced prospects. He and other Brit firms lost money continually on B/W projects. To compete with Hollywood needed outlay at least close to what Yanks routinely spent, but selling in US territory was a mountain highest to scale, even good ones like Elephant Boy and Rembrandt seeing loss at final accounting. The Drum would beat that with best earnings Korda saw since The Scarlet Pimpernel and The Private Life of Henry VIII, latter bawdy after expectation where much-married Henry was center subject. The Drum got $1.8 million in worldwide rentals against $691K spent on the negative, a bargain being it was color. Less dependence on dialogue helped The Drum travel easier, foreign receipts amounting to over a million, the story centered on Empire struggle against India insurgents led by Raymond Massey, who like all best native villains, speaks impeccable King’s English having been educated alongside his to-be enemies. Tense exchanges between Massey and stalwart Robert Livesey are a particular highlight of The Drum, as is support Valerie Hobson, Francis L. Sullivan, and top-billed Sabu, a biggest star so far incubated by Korda. Bloodletting is held till a finish, then bodies drop decorously in the face of machine guns and varied explosives, this all to word-of-mouth benefit. The Drum was retitled Drums for US markets, and since multiple drums are in play, why not? Ahead would be Four Feathers and The Thief of Bagdad, both also in Technicolor, as successful, more so in fact, and evergreen for purpose of reissues through the forties. Alan Barbour wrote of going in packs wherever they played, such being high regard in which the Korda group was held. My Region Two disc of The Drum looks fine. Even better would be a Blu-Ray release, but I know not at this point who domestic-owns it.
FIVE FINGERS (1952) --- Next time you teach Great Screenwriting, if that’s even relevant anymore, use Five Fingers as power point. It’s another to tell us the war was won but by skin of teeth. Makes me nervous watching even after eighty years. Were Germans really informed of Normandy for site of D-Day, choosing to ignore it as undoubted Allied trickery? Five Fingers says yes, as later would 36 Hours, others. Then there was The Man Who Never Was where Clifton Webb led a disinformation campaign to divert Germans from spot where the invasion would happen. Enough intrigue like this and I could wonder if Germany would have believed info sourced from the White House itself, suspicion and mistrust being what they were on both sides (especially theirs we’re always told). Fun of war drama is the enemy always outwitting themselves, but how close really did Germany come to learning vital secrets? Five Fingers says close enough to have dope right from our ambassador’s Turkish headquarter, him in receipt of strategy the Germans largely ignored for not trusting data, or each other. Did we win thanks to unbridled paranoia across whole of the Axis command? James Mason is the valet who steals documents and photographs them. All this was based on fact and a book called “Operation Cicero.” Mason sells info not for treason sake but simply for money, irony his being paid all along in counterfeit currency printed by the Germans. So how much counterfeiting did they actually do during the war? Enough to eventually wreck Allied economies? Did they print phony American bills? Five Fingers should be on Blu-Ray but isn’t. Unfortunately it is a Fox picture, which means Disney owns it and you know the rest. There was a Fox “On Demand” disc released years back, merely OK but not what we’d prefer. Bernard Herrmann’s score would be reason to watch even if Five Fingers were not the fiercely clever and entertaining show it is.
13 Comments:
I love the reissue poster by Osvaldo Venturi for THE DRUM / RUNS than any of the artwork made for the English markets.
We might’ve been at that same Manhattan paper show, John. I recall seeing Ms Keaton strolling from table to table with a smile on her face, and as she passed by, dealers hurried to mark up their prices. It seemed a transitional moment when a fan’s hobby suddenly morphed into big business. (Heck, I can remember buying original stills of the Stooges in SOUP TO NUTS for 25 cents apiece!)
Five Fingers has long been a favourite of mine but it's a spy drama that doesn't seem to get the special amount of appreciation that it rightfully deserves. Highly intelligent screenplay, with fine, droll performances by all involved, not to mention that great Bernard Herrman score to which you referred.
The dialogue is often a particular delight, with my favourite line spoken by Danielle Darrieux as a countess of no convictions except the desire to live in luxury.
When she sees a German courier of meager means observing her admiringly Darrieux coolly intones, "Please do not look at me as if you had a source of income other than your salary."
Now that is an elegant way of telling a man to take a hike while also acknowledging that, for the right price, she's for sale!
Walked by esteemed film dealer Omar Whayne's table and told him I'd just met Diane Keaton, to which Omar, with a quizzical expression, asked "She any kin to Buster?"
I saw Goodbar on its original release, and didn't enjoy it either. It seemed like it was made up of three scenes repeated for two hours: 1) Keaton at work (as an elementary school teacher as I recall); 2) Keaton at a disco; 3) Keaton getting laid by a stranger. I thought it was actually pretty boring.
As for "5 Fingers", it was remade (much shorter) as an episode of "The 20th Century Fox Hour" under the title "Operation Cicero". Ricardo Montalban is in the James Mason role, and he's quite good. Peter Lorre has a supporting part. Having watched the trailer for "5 Fingers", it was easy to see which sets and exterior shots were used for the TV version.
One more thing. Being a proud New Yorker, I had to fast forward through Hatful of Rain to see the location shots. At some point, Eva Marie Saint leaves a building near the Flatiron Building on 15th Street, seems to turn a corner to enter the subway with the Empire State Building in the background (35th Street), and exits near the Brooklyn Bridge. There are more direct ways to get home than that.
In the pre internet age I knew some folks who went to see Goodbar thinking it was a light Woody Allen like comedy. Ah nope.
Never thought of that ... it does have a misleading title. Imagine surprise for those going in for a light romantic comedy and getting GOODBAR instead.
Dan Mercer considers misleading movies:
That's an amusing thought, going to see "Looking for Mr. Goodbar" thinking that it was a light comedy.
And waiting for the fun to begin.
It's like the time my wife and I took my mother to see "The Painted Veil," which is, of course, set during a cholera epidemic and has some pretty grim scenes in it.
Afterwards, as we leaving the theater, she said, "You know, there weren't a lot of laughs in that one."
On my first liberty out of Navy boot camp in San Diego in 1979 I walked into a used magazine and bookstore looking for some reading material. I found a humor magazine from 1947. It had Bob Hope on the cover with a Carmen Miranda fruit hat on with the quote "You'll find many laffs in this magazine or I'll eat my hat." While flipping through it I found a Stooges still from EVEN AS I.O.U. I went to the counter to buy the magazine and pulled the still out. I could have left it in the magazine and ripped the store off. The proprietor looked like he walked out of a movie, bald, gruff, cigar, myopic. He said "Your honesty will get you nowhere. That's a buck for the still." My first Stooge still for a buck!
Dan Mercer appreciates Valerie Hobson ... as do we all:
I first became aware of Valarie Hobson, or at least took notice of her as such, when I watched David Lean's "Great Expectations." She was playing the adult Estella and I couldn't imagine her as having grown up from the beautiful, exquisitely haughty Estella of Jean Simmons, then an object of deepening infatuation on my part. Only much later did I realize that I had encountered her before, as Elizabeth in James Whale's "Bride of Frankenstein." Only 17 when this was made, she was like a blossoming orchid, lush and overwrought. Still later, I found her in minor British efforts, such as "This Man is News" and "Q Planes," in which her performances were most acceptable as young women open to the idea of fun and adventure. She was also of a physical "type" that I found myself increasingly attracted to. The lobby card from "The Drum" suggests her appearance, the tall, slender figure, the long face with strong nose, large eyes, full lips, and pointed chin. Some might refer to her as a "palomino." When I finally saw "Great Expectations" again, however, I was able to see her performance for what it was, a very good, nuanced one that grew out of the earlier, much younger Estella of Jean Simmons, who would only have been about the age Hobson had been in "Bride of Frankenstein." She is not the minx that Simmons was, having attained a womanly depth and beauty, but this only meant that a rapier can often be left sheathed. I knew that such a one could wound me at a touch...or a glance.
Always happy to see the sublime Valerie Hobson appreciated anew. Here's a blog post of mine from many years ago. Since then I've caught up with even more of her fine work (her other Universal monster classic "Werewolf of London"(1935) with Henry Hull and the late career "The Voice of Merrill" from 1952 in which she's perfection. Anyway here's the post:
VALERIE HOBSON in “The Card”
Ms Hobson had long been an estimable name in the British film world when she appeared in “The Card”. With 20 years of film experience behind her, including a mid-30’s sojourn as a Universal contract player in Hollywood. There she displayed uncommon poise (especially considering she was still a teenager) as Dr. Frankenstein’s actual bride in “Bride of Frankenstein”. Returning to Britain, she married rising film producer/screenwriter Anthony Havelock-Allen. This connection may have given her an inside track when it came to snagging choice film parts, but it was her consistently commendable work, once she got them, that made her a star. The immediate post-war years stand as her golden era – “Great Expectations” and “Kind Hearts and Coronets” made world-wide splashes. British audiences happily queued to see her in the bang-up bodice-ripper “Blanche Fury”. It had all the deluxe Technicolor trappings of the genre (including Stewart Granger to romance her) and Hobson shone commandingly at its center. Her presence also enriched “The Interrupted Journey”, a Hitchcockian thriller with Richard Todd, which -even with an unfortunate last minute plot twist - remains an almost perfect film. She capped off the decade with probably her greatest performance – in “The Rocking Horse Winner” - as the patrician mother whose need for luxury destroys her family.
“The Card” was part of Alec Guinness’ early 50’s run as the golden boy of the British cinema. A sly period comedy, it follows a low-born but ambitious law-clerk’s rise to prominence. By hook or by crook. That trajectory brings him into contact with several ladies (Glynis Johns, Petula Clark and Valerie Hobson, all in fine form). Hobson’s the Countess of Chell. Described early on by Guinness’ character as “the finest woman that ever came to this town”, she lives up to the description. A splendid (and quite unique) mix of hauteur and merriment. Effortlessly conveying both good-natured refinement and airy intelligence. She’s an aristocratic dream in the role, but also manages to make the character penetrating, practical, affable and adaptable. Definitely up to any occasion. And serenely aware that her presence confers dignity on even the most undignified situations. In one scene, her coachman warns Guinness that milady’s “in an awful temper”. But when she glides into public view she couldn’t be more gracious. It’s hard to imagine any other actress carrying this part off with even half the flair and charm Hobson brings to it. At very least, it’s a performance Oscar should’ve taken note of in ’52. Having finished “The Card”, Valerie Hobson sailed on to one more triumph. This time on the stage, headlining the original London production of “The King and I” (opposite Herbert Lom). A smash hit, it saw Hobson dispensing onstage all the charm, elegance and artistry that had marked her film work – and – oh, yes, she also revealed a lovely singing voice no one even knew she had. A woman of infinite accomplishment.
Hate to be the Well, Actually guy, but The Man Who Never Was (a favorite true life yarn of mine, in both of its film versions as well as the original book) is actually about convincing the Germans that the 1943 landing in Sicily would be somewhere else-- not D-Day.
There's a more accurate (and more seedy) version called Operation Mincemeat, well enough done, but I'll always love Clifton Webb, Robert Flemyng, Miles Malleson etc. Broke my heart to learn that the meeting with the Welsh corpse's father was complete fiction-- it's a great scene ("You people always say English when you mean British.")
Post a Comment
<< Home