Ads and Oddities #12
![]() |
| What This Book Tells Will Surprise You Plenty. Go Get It. |
Ad/Odds: Drews Delight in New Book, Mac/Eddy a 60's Happening, Cooped Up Lost World Watchers, and What Got Looked At Twenty Years Back
![]() |
| They Go Way Back but Still Are Funny for My Money |
PRESENTING MR. AND MRS. SIDNEY DREW --- Neither odd nor an ad, this instead a new book by Rob Farr that explores the lives of Sidney Drew and the two Mrs. Drews, first who appeared with him on stage with second spouse filling in for movies after death of the first. Greenbriar has on several occasions dropped in on the Drews. They were funny on “genial” terms of comedy that stopped short of slapstick, deliberate device to set them apart from Sennett. For all their mirthing, no Drew threw a pie to my knowledge. They were successors in a sense to John Bunny who also got laughs from expression and reaction to absurd situations, stuff that could happen to any of us his fodder for fun. Bunny died premature and the Drews sort of took up his mantle. Author Farr does not confine himself just to their films however. There was stage drudge before to remind us how artists starved and struggled along inhospitable rail lines and tank towns where one night stands were misery few among moderns could stand, never mind dedication to art or craft. Sidney Drew was kin to the Barrymores. Farr explains the links and that enriches his telling of the Drew saga. Sidney was often (nearly always?) broke on the road, threatened with jail, stranded troupes, poor attendance, bombing in Butte and other sites, stiffing a hotel, threatened with a pistol and/or carving knife, dragged off a train and bashed for owing someone or other. Such actor’s life would sure not have been for me or thee I’d venture. We all would take vanilla after reading the Drews’ harrowing account. Rob Farr knows vaudeville plus film lore and recounts it beautifully. This is show history not to be put down, and for sure enriches whatever we watch of the Drews from now on (Rob Stone indicates a Blu-ray collection is coming). In a meantime, the Drews are spread amongst silent and comedy DVD/Blu collections. Kino’s of-late Vitagraph disc set has much of Drew humor and is not to be missed. HERE is where to order Rob Farr's Mr. and Mrs. Drew book.
![]() |
| Forget Bonnie and Clyde or The Graduate During the Sixties. This Was the Goods. |
WHEN MACDONALD/EDDY GOT HOT AGAIN --- Alarming to think that during the sixties as beatniks gave way to hippies and everyone did the Limbo or Twist, and don’t forget we were “losing our innocence” that whole time … well, along comes Jeanette MacDonald and Nelson Eddy to reassert true glory in filmed entertainment of yore. The pair had adherents still, older maybe but ambulating still to local cinemas where Mac/Eddy asserted charm intact despite thirty years since same songbirds made magic. Theirs were jewels amidst operettas salted among MGM’s “Perpetual Products,” a category invented by Metro marketers and trade shorthand for movies still viable no matter how old or familiar from TV. MacDonald and Eddy served best as a communal experience, kindreds sat in seats where music could waft about them as if the pair were live concerting. All recalled impact these features had when movie viewing was a different and shared experience. Ponder figures: The Girl of the Golden West (1938) had 637 revival bookings between September 1, 1962 and August 31, 1967. $20,540 was collected by Leo at average rentals of $32 per date. Perpetuals were generally used on slow Tuesdays or whatever wasn’t prime weekend time. $20,540 may not have been a windfall, but then again, for a 1939 title that wasn’t The Wizard of Oz or GWTW, well, yeah, it was a windfall, especially if you were a Metro field man who’d long given up on oldies as useful product. It got better: Mac/Eddy in Sweethearts (also 1938) seized 802 dates, collected $31,772 at average $40 rental. How long would graying patronage hold out? Not forever of course. Fanship for the team would fade as expected as would willingness to line up and buy tickets for fare free at home. Stimulating the more was not having to stay up (too) late, endure endless commercials plus cuts to see/hear favorites again. Fans are still out there for Mac/Eddy, more I suspect than we realize. Consider too that MGM had a hundred more vaulties in theatrical circulation through the sixties, many in circulation even unto the eighties (I saw The Secret Garden at a Gastonia, NC matinee in 1981). Warner Archive offers Technicolored Sweethearts on Blu-ray, and more recently, Rose Marie. I hope both sell well and inspire more.HOW EXCESSIVE IS 133 FEATURES IN FIVE MONTHS? --- Might as well ask depth of spirits consumed in a night, how many chocolate chip cookies ate in a sitting, any habit over-indulged. Seems we watch less features than before, sample or skip the tendency, attention deficit ruling days plus nights. You could claim it’s plight of the young, but what if change is wider spread among ages, everybody now afflicted. Too many glasses left mostly full, thirty second sips or none. I look at features in whole and feel a last left to do so. Saw three in a gulp one recent night, Angels With Dirty Faces, Three Smart Girls, and Them!. Latter was new-arrived 4K, the others Blu-Ray. A picnic and no red ants as with analog happily passed. How different was life in 2004-05? No less than change wrought over any passage of twenty years. We had DVD by then, film collecting going if not gone (but wait, recently it has roared back). Too few classics were had on disc by 2004. A lot was seen off TCM and other satellite outlets, some broadcast in High-Definition. That by itself was reason to watch Woman of Straw, Queen of Blood, or Fun in Acapulco where otherwise you might ignore them. The James Bond series was showing up in HD on HBO, Showtime, here/there. Lacking wherewithal to record and save them meant setting alarm for four am one January ‘05 morn to watch On Her Majesty’s Secret Service and Diamonds Are Forever. I couldn’t say what the “Best” film was from this 04-05 list, but do recall the “Worst,” Star for sure as complete heaven-help-me roadshow on a Fox DVD. Had never seen it, hope not to again. Not sure I got through to the end. A few of the 133 have screened again so far in 2026, Dial M for Murder, Mogambo, The Big Broadcast of 1938, Son of Dracula, la Dolce Vita, International House, How to Steal a Million, They Came to Cordura, Blow-Up, Helen of Troy, and Khartoum, most the fruit of Blu-Ray or 4K releasing. Certain favorites have been screened at least a dozen more times since 04-05: Giant, The 39 Steps, Vera Cruz, The Big Clock, Across the Pacific, Planet of the Vampires, Strangers on a Train, other evergreens. Fact is all 133 would rate an encore, 132 if I exclude Star. Latter could happen in hope opinion might change with two decade growth and increased tolerance for 60’s elephant art.
![]() |
| Says Projectionist: My Cigar's Gone Dead, Pal. Got a Light? |
LOST TO THIS WORLD HAD FILM CAUGHT FIRE --- Of all times and places I’d not revisit, even if option were open to me, here is one to rank highest. It’s a topic addressed before, The Lost World as airborne featured attraction on a passenger flight, hosted by Imperial Airways Ltd., a British firm. Lately I found a slightly different and much clearer image from the well-publicized 1925 event. There also is capture of the plane’s interior that shows seating, resumed capacity for eight not including pilots (bring back wicker chairs for flying, I say). Occupants would traverse the North Sea. Is that near where Leslie Howard was shot down in 1943? I spoke before to insanity of running 35mm nitrate at high altitude with no means of emergency egress. Do you suppose Imperial permitted smoking aboard? Bet they did, not unlike Moon Mullins stood in his film storage shed during hot-as-hell July sans shirt and rewinding nitrate. I was as reckless for helping him. Was risk worth an Out of the Past trailer Moon peeled off and gave me? The Lost World experiment appears to be the first time a feature film was shown aboard a plane for the amusement of passengers. Years later (1961), the first regularly scheduled in-air movie was By Love Possessed. Collectors would refer to these as “airline prints” and mixed bags they were, quality-wise. There were sticky fingered lab employees to sell same out back doors to dealers who’d sell same at weekend Meadowland shows. This was early-to-mid eighties when Universal was still ordering 16mm prints of stuff they controlled for use as in-flight entertainment, final days for exhibition of celluloid aboard planes. Among titles were Hitchcock and Howard Hughes properties U controlled (and still do): Vertigo, Hell’s Angels, Scarface, Rope, others. All were “original” prints and hot-sought. Air travelers now watch movies on the back of a seat in front of them, or on devices they bring aboard. Progress to be sure, no one fated to a screen visible whether you liked it or not.








17 Comments:
Sidney Drew directed and stars in "A Florida Enchantment" (1914), a very strange and literally provocative movie. Does the book discuss it?
It opens as a standard polite comedy .Drew's character is identified as "a young doctor" (intentional joke?) with a pretty young fiancee. The fiancee and her blackface maid, under the titular enchantment, both slowly turn into men and establish new male identities. The movie unfolds as if this was an innocent drawing room farce. Then, near the end, Drew's character abruptly turns into a manic Charley Aunt for a slapstick wrap-up. It's as if this were a live play bombing, and director Drew decided to run onstage in a dress.
Farr's book covers all the Drew films in gratifying detail.
I had an airline 16mm print of THE FOUR MUSKETEERS. The death/execution of Milady, the villain, was missing.
Your post about Eddy and MacDonald reminds me of a retrospective in Boston years ago. During the summer months the Boston Public Library held weekly screenings that were open to the public, with no admission charged. The first was a series of Fred Astaire-Ginger Rogers musicals. These were so popular that the series was repeated the following summer. Instead of bringing the same films back the third time around, the film librarian opted instead for Nelson Eddy and Jeanette MacDonald, dubious about their appeal in the wake of Astaire and Rogers but hoping for the best.
Imagine his surprise when the attendance surpassed the Astaire-Rogers audiences, with standing-room-only crowds in the auditorium.
The follow-up was a series of Irving Berlin musicals. The librarian really wanted to include ON THE AVENUE, only to be told by the rental agency that Mr. Berlin himself personally withdrew the film from circulation. Undaunted, the librarian wrote a formal letter to Mr. Berlin, asking permission to show the film. Mr. Berlin consented, and everyone in the audience (myself included) had a delightful time.
Incidentally, I'm happy to report that I am related to Jeanette MacDonald and her sister Edith (known to movie buffs as Marie Blake and to TV fans as Blossom Rock of The Addams Family. (I'm also related to Johnny Mack Brown, for what that's worth!)
I salute your wide-open choice of movies, and keeping track of them, too. My choices tend to be pre-1960, usually pre-1940, with emphasis on 65-75 minute features to cram in even more. My own blog often gets around to the obscure stuff I believe worth talking about, and I'm astounded how many there are -- and it doesn't include the ones I don't mention. I find as I get older that if a movie doesn't spark my interest after the first reel, it's time to switch it off.
I had a gorgeous tech IB airline 16mm print of Paint Your Wagon, which I screened many times back in the late 70's, early 80's. Years later, when it became available on video, I couldn't believe how much was missing from that shortened print (which actually retained an intermission title!), as I recall, a couple of songs and a few unimportant scenes. Being the bloated show it was, it was probably a better edit!
Scott, where did your librarian locate a print of ON THE AVENUE? Did Berlin's people supply it? I recall that as being an exceedingly rare title on 16mm.
Mt friend Bill Wootten In Statesville rented a week's worth of Deanna Durbin features for a local art guild's salute to Deanna. This was around the mid-seventies, and the programs were well attended and much-liked. I'm wondering if any Durbin films were revived anywhere theatrically during this time period. If not, they sure should have been.
Hey Kevin, somewhere in deep storage I have the 1968 list of watched movies. Soon as it resurfaces, which it surely will because I know it's not lost, just misplaced, I'll include same in an upcoming Ad/Oddities.
Prospect of watching PAINT YOUR WAGON truly scares me, so I never have.
Was this foolish narrow-mindedness on my part like with other features ducked as persistently?
Richard M. Roberts shares some thoughts about this week's subjects:
John,
I concur in your recommendation of Rob Farr's Mr. and Mrs. Sidney Drew book, a great read about an unjustly and important early comedy team that also has a pretty good foreward by some tall guy.....what's his name?
It took the passing of years to develop an appreciation for MacDonald and Eddy. I preferred Jeanette singing in her lingerie and paired with Maurice Chevalier rather than being MGM'ed and post-coded into stodginess, but over the years I ended up watching their films usually to check them off some other actor's list who had appeared with them: John Barrymore in MAYTIME (1937), Jimmy Stewart in ROSE MARIE (1936), the remnants of Buster Keaton's mostly-deleted and unbilled part in NEW MOON (1940), and a boatload of comedians in THE GIRL OF THE GOLDEN WEST (1938). And by the time I had gone through those titles, I realized I didn't mind Jeanette and Nelson at all, and that their films were perfectly entertaining in their own right.
Airline prints were indeed ubiquitous in collectors circles in the 70's and 80's, and one problem with them was the fact that the films could indeed be trimmed to fit a specific flight time. I had a nice IB Tech airline print of 1776 that was missing a song and scene or two as well, though it may have also been just the general release version that had been considerably cut from the original preview and road-show version which I had been fortunate to see in the theater. PAINT YOUR WAGON was also rather trimmed in it's general release.
BTW John, you should have no fear of watching PAINT YOUR WAGON, I saw it in it's original roadshow release too and have always enjoyed it just fine. Just gird yourself for Clint Eastwood singing and all will be well.
RICHARD M ROBERTS
I recall a lot of airline prints being printed on mylar stock, a lot of those subject to scratching, so I was apprehensive about taking any that could not be screened in advance.
In initial release "1776" lost the song "Cool Cool Conservative Men", reportedly because it offended Jack Warner's friend Richard Nixon. After both gentlemen passed, the song was restored with a bit of fanfare.
Dan Mercer has more details about the in-flight "Lost World" show:
The celebrated first in-flight motion picture showing took place on April 6, 1925 aboard the Imperial Airways “City of Washington,” a Handley Page W8F airliner with three-engines, biplane configuration, and seats for 12 passengers. The flight was from London to Paris and took two hours and twenty minutes, so there was time enough for a complete showing of “The Lost World.” Imperial Airways prohibited smoking on their flights, but that is almost beside the point. Given the extraordinary measures theaters then took to show nitrate prints safely, it would have required a special kind of madness to stage such a stunt on a largely fabric and wood airplane. A bit of turbulence, a jam in the hot projector—projected image of film being consumed—then the projectionist pushing past the passengers to assure the pilot and co-pilot, “We’ve had it, mates!” I understand that First National released a shortened Kodascope version of the film on 16 mm safety film in February 1925, so there is the possibility that that was the one used for the show, though I can only guess from the picture of the film equipment being put on board whether it was 35 mm or 16 mm. If it was the Kodascope version, however, this would also have been the first example of a shortened print used for an in-flight showing.
John, the print of ON THE AVENUE -- like everything else the film librarian rented, his was a 16mm venue -- came from Films Incorporated. They absolutely would not let ON THE AVENUE out because it was restricted by Irving Berlin. This was in the mid-1980s, when Berlin was in his late nineties, and Berlin made a lot of people happy that night. I also applaud the librarian, who went the extra mile to approach Irving Berlin personally.
Dan Mercer came across some really neat old Hollywood home movies:
You might enjoy these home movies, which were donated many years ago by a woman called Lauretta Edlund to the UCLA Film & Television Archive, but which have just become available:
https://www.facebook.com/UCLAFTVArchive/videos/poolside-with-the-stars-of-1930s-hollywood-%EF%B8%8Flauretta-edlund-home-movies-santa-mo/1713608583008751/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rwDshqcXCqY
Edlund was the sister (or niece, depending on the source) of Lady Sylvia Ashley, who married Douglas Fairbanks, Sr., the swashbuckling star of silent films, in April 1936. A title card reads "All walking scenes directed by SYLVIA." Fairbanks and such friends as Charles Chaplin and Fred Astaire are featured in the clips. Merle Oberon, who is also in many of them, had come to California in 1936 to do "Beloved Enemy" for Goldwyn, which received its theatrical release on December 25, 1936. LIFE, which featured the movie, included pictures of the new British star with her American friend, Norma Shearer, who is also in some of the clips. So, a reasonable estimate of the time period of these home movies would be around the summer of 1936.
"Merle and David" refers to Oberon and David Niven, her beau at the time. The clip, "Norma, Merle, and Benita," shows Norma Shearer, looking quite lovely, Benita Hulme, and a perky Merle Oberon.
Astaire, stylishly dressed as ever, evidently wore his toupee only in performance.
Fairbanks, who would die on December 12, 1939 of a heart attack, had been suffering from congestive heart failure for several months prior to his death. In these clips, however, he seems quite robust, wrestling with dogs and mimicking Astaire's steps.
It would appear that never was there a time when Chaplin was not "on."
Possibly the star who appeals to me most is Fay Wray, who appears in the complete collection, found under the second link.
What's especially interesting is how these people act when a home movie camera is turned on. They were movie stars and acted for a living before the camera, but let the camera be an 8 mm home movie one, and they frolic and cavort and try to do funny things just like regular people would have done then. One who doesn't, though, is Fay Wray, who appears very much as herself, from what I've read about her, as someone intelligent and thoughtful and gentle.
The home movies were taken on Kodachrome and the color is sadly faded for most of the clips. I think that they're terrific despite that, but would love to have them restored to their original appearance.
Kodachrome film does not fade, some of these home movies were unfortunately overexposed when they were shot, whomever was shooting is shooting at the wrong F-stop.
But they are amazing home movies. Did anyone notice Chaplin is playing tennis with Groucho Marx at one point, and Paulette Goddard is there with Chaplin in some of the later footage. And we see Eddie Cantor and Daryl F. Zanuck in some of the last footage shown.
It's nice to see Fairbanks Sr looking happy and relaxed in the footage, we hear so much gossip about how sad and unhappy he was being married to Ashley, perhaps some of this footage shows that gossip to be just that.
RICHARD M ROBERTS
On my very first night on the internet I searched for silent film comedy. One of the hits led me to a site called MUGSHOTS. So well made and VERY informative. This initial stand for silent film comedy on the internet was started by Rob Farr. I'm am so glad I printed the website on paper for it is long gone now. Later I found out Rob attended the Liberty Tent of the Sons Of The Desert in Englewood, Colorado, which I helped found some fifty years ago. We named it the Liberty Tent after the country's bicentennial. Nearly 30 years later he showed me how to navigate the Madison Building reading room at the LOC, a help I have never forgot. Having been acquainted with Rob for many years, I can assure you anything he writes about silent film comedy you can hang your hat on. His writing style is engaging and not dry historical dissertation. I highly recommend buying this book even if you are not into the subject matter. Rob helped found Slapticon for which he shall see the kingdom of heaven.
Post a Comment
<< Home