Making MGM Melodies More Regular
Broadway Melody of 1936 --- So New It Was a Year Ahead
Radio was king of beasts Hollywood tamed to use/advantage from arrival of talkies when the two could parlay and mutually benefit from shared talent. The majors bought interest in broadcasting to wet beaks in homes plus theatres. Paramount did the duet best, in fact called their revue series The Big Broadcast(s), with International House further instance at harnessing the ether. Metro looked more to Broadway flash than noise from a box, so radio, if referenced, was done so in spoofing terms, Jack Benny a Winchell-derived smart aleck on-air who takes regular beatings for forgetting his place. Columnists were threatened before, at least fictionally, Lee Tracy shot at in Blessed Event, crime reporters oft-clay pigeons for organized thuggery. How hot under collars did Broadway dwellers get with gossip mongers like Winchell? Enough so to wound or kill? Depends I’d guess on what or how much was at stake where squibs took aim. I’m told Winchell himself got warned for taking on gangland interests and even foreign depredations (the Hitler menace). Recall suggests he got worked over a few times, and you wonder if such incidents were not more frequent but kept quiet for any number of sound reasons. Was Winchell made to back off powers too powerful even for his jaws to crack? An honest WW memoir would sure have made valuable history.
Robert Taylor as an aggrieved stage producer walks boldly into Benny’s newspaper sanctum, on three occasions, to knock the upstart cold. I’d like knowing how often this happened in real life. Story has it that Grace Kelly’s father showed up at Confidential offices and shellacked its editor, this on 50’s occasion when the mag dished dirt on the future princess. More than one of Melody’s cast refers to New York as a cold and heartless town, clearly spoken for the screenwriters, and said sincerely. For all of times we were warned to stay home, leave Broadway and certainly Hollywood, alone, this was mere recital of show world writ. Wasn’t it enough to have movies to follow and pay admissions to, or road companies to patronize, even perhaps a White Way show when visiting that cruelest of cities? Wonder how fulfilling it was to pursue a career, however successfully, if you regarded the place as such a cesspool. Eleanor Powell is the neophyte down from Albany to conquer B’way, us to assume Albany was all thatched roofed with apple pies on sills, broad defining of a “small” town. Powell and Robert Taylor were stars not fully lit in 1935. In fact, this was her first lead, just like in the movies you could say, except here we are asked to aid in the creation of new personalities by cheering Powell and boosting Bob. How pliable was a 1935-36 public toward manufacture of stars?
Eleanor Powell could dance up storms, did so for seasons to come, then one day, no longer would. Did she quit, move on, for her own reasons, or did Metro give up on her? Something always seemed missing in Powell, however great she was on taps. More data I need to get straight … were tap sounds always dubbed in after the fact? I asked someone once and they looked at me like I was stupid and said, Well, of course they are. So tell please, am I stupid? Will say that Eleanor Powell does dead-on impersonating of Katharine Hepburn in Morning Glory, less caricature than true-accurate capture of Hepburn’s voice and mannerisms. Metro had backed B'way plays toward screen adaptation; that's how Grand Hotel incubated, so Leo figured himself as much impresario of stage as screen. What Hollywood sought was domination of all entertainment media, this to propel oligopolies a Justice Department finally shut down, restraint years away from being applied, so in a meantime, Metro offered up Broadway shows they'd swear to beat the real thing.
"A Brave Love Story That Smiles Through The Heartbreak" they called it, as what was anyone's musical without boy/girl interest, thus romancers w/o song pressed into singing songs, in this case Robert Taylor who'd not hide behind dubbers any more than James Stewart did for Born To Dance, which followed Broadway Melody of 1936 by less than a year. Versatility was required of contract players, lead men to sing where parts called for it.
Performing standouts Eleanor Powell and Frances Langford had begun in presentation houses, that is, theatres that offered stage plus screen programs. Powell stole shows doing single numbers, her talent like something beyond nature's capacity. Notice by Variety and other trades made it inevitable she'd be drafted into movies, as was case with Langford, who sang on crowded bills but, said trade reviewing, clung too closely to the mike and so hid her features from the audience. These issues were of course ironed out for Broadway Melody of 1936, and besides, locus of build-up was Eleanor Powell, who took hellish ordeal putting over tap routines that cost four toenails off her right foot for a start, and left both so swollen that she dared not remove slippers for fear she couldn't put them on again. Such backstage realities come under heading of grim price paid for placement in lights. From such suffering came an unearthly kind of performing perfection, not just from Eleanor Powell, but most any that qualified for inclusion in an MGM musical. I readily understand how all of them thought it would last forever. The fiefdom within a fiefdom stayed impregnable a long time. Small wonder that compiling of the best of it for That’s Entertainment took viewers’ breath away. They had forgotten, or never knew, what an empire of song and dance had come and gone. Broadway Melody Of 1936 streams in HD, on TCM, and is DVD available.
























































