Green For Danger (1947) is Who Done It For The Ages
Yank trades sure kept UK pics on the grill over
what reads like hostile environment for imports, showmen outside art housing
egging on discontent with outsider product flopping within our walls. Even most
gracious Brit visitors got the ice, as here when Variety damned Green For
Danger with faintest praise: "Very acceptable mystery film but hardly one
that warrants giving Hollywood back to the Indians," cute at
expense of what I'd call a masterpiece of whodunits, foreign or domestic. You
know a mystery works when you're immersed enough in the set-up to forget
there's going to be (has to be) murder within a next reel, this by way of
saying the thing works well outside genre convention. Here is occasion where we
really can defy guest viewers to guess the killer. Credit for that goes to
writing/directing (and co-producer) Sidney Gilliat, whose name on UK credits
make any a must to watch, his wit having enhanced The Lady Vanishes, Night Train To Munich, numerous others.
I've seen Green For Danger numerous times and
still am surprised by the reveal. Follow closely and rewards are
great, most memorably the great Alastair Sim as oddball Inspector Cockrell, a
fabulous creation you could wish upon a series of thrillers over decades to
follow, but regrettably this was a one and only case for Cockrell,
though Sim would approximate him elsewhere. The actor, his performance, and
Green For Danger itself were of such unconventional type as to put columnists
to search of fresh accolades. Highest praise for the film would come from
outside trade establishment like Variety protecting borders. Rave reviewing compared
Green For Danger to The Thin Man and the best of Sherlock Holmes. Syndicated Billy
Rose wrote that "it makes Hollywood's
latest shoot-'em-ups look like pillow fights in a girl's dormitory," and
called Alastair Sim a "civilized funnyman."
In fact, Sim's acerbic
Cockrell was funny to extent of one's appetite for blackest of humor and
character capacity to switch suddenly from apparent buffoon to sly and
efficient investigator. Cockrell would see modern tribute in the person of
Columbo and other sleuths habitually underestimated. Green For Danger was
US-handled by Eagle-Lion, which got J. Arthur Rank leavings after Universal
creamed best of his for distribution (E-L dealt twelve from Rank during
1948). Initial dates were LA saturated as second feature to E-L's Repeat
Performance, while New York play at the Winter Garden yielded $16K over a first
four days, unusually good for an import minus marquee lure.
What lit Gotham was rave notices from critics
previewed by Eagle-Lion, the latter knowing it had strong merchandise to ride
reviewer wave toward further word-of-mouth from satisfied patrons. A good
enough picture could catch on thus where newspapers and radio guided movie
choices, "smart" shows like Green For Danger a hook for those seeking
something out of the ordinary. Airwave support was a big help, WOR running
week-long contests tied to Green For Danger and conducting interviews with
visiting star Leo Genn. Eagle-Lion had itself an urban hit if not one that
would click in the heartland. As distribution rights reverted back to J. Arthur
Rank, Green For Danger and others of his would be handled by Allied Films, Inc.
for 1951 reissue. TV soon got the leavings, Green For Danger, like others of
Rank origin, an early arrival to home consumption. Criterion offers a splendid DVD, and TCM has played Green For Danger occasionally in HD.